top of page

Three Ways of Asking Spain for Its Trust

5 hours ago
12 min read

Pedro Sánchez wants his record in office to be recognised. Alberto Núñez Feijóo is asking voters to give credit to an alternative that has not yet governed Spain. Ada Colau is returning with the experience of someone who tried to transform institutions from within. Their conversations with Jordi Wild leave a question that no campaign can resolve with a slogan: what reasons do we have to believe them?

There is one word that barely needs to be spoken to be present in all three interviews: trust.

Pedro Sánchez asks for it when he explains why he wants to remain in office after eight years at La Moncloa. Alberto Núñez Feijóo seeks it when presenting a programme that he has not yet had to implement from the central government. Ada Colau needs it to justify a return she had previously ruled out and a candidacy that has failed to bring together all the left-wing forces she intended to unite.

They are not asking for exactly the same thing.

Sánchez wants his achievements to be recognised. Feijóo offers his experience as a guarantee of what he could do. Colau champions causes she considers urgent, but she returns with an institutional record that can already be assessed.

The distinction matters because Spanish politics often compares promises and results as though they were equivalent. They are not. An announcement about housing is not a home that has been delivered. A proposal to save money is not money actually saved. A declaration of principles does not demonstrate what will happen when it becomes necessary to negotiate with an uncomfortable coalition partner.

The conversations on The Wild Project are interesting precisely because they allow us to observe these differences outside conventional political interview formats. Jordi Wild does not organise a debate between candidates, nor does he attempt to follow every convention of political journalism. He asks questions driven by curiosity, his own concerns and, at times, issues that have been circulating on social media for weeks.

His style has advantages and limitations. He can persist with a specific question when an answer appears to move away from it. He can also introduce assumptions that require more scrutiny than a conversation allows. The result is not an exhaustive audit, but it does provide an opportunity to hear how three political leaders reason when they do not have their usual control over the direction of an interview.

Nor were they interviewed under equal conditions. The conversations lasted different lengths of time, did not cover exactly the same issues and Santiago Abascal, whose participation had been planned, ultimately did not attend. These limitations should be remembered before turning the interviews into a competition with winners and losers.

The most useful approach is not to decide who performed most brilliantly, but to observe what each candidate does when a question reaches the point at which their political message becomes uncomfortable.

The weight of what has already been done

Sánchez faces the most direct examination of the central government's record. He can talk about legislation, investment and agreements. He has a record to present and direct responsibility for the results.

When Wild asks him about the 184,000 public and affordable homes announced by his government, the conversation reveals a very specific difficulty. The prime minister can describe projects under way, but at that moment he does not provide an exact figure for homes that have actually been delivered and occupied. Projects are necessary, but so is distinguishing them from results that are already available.

Something similar happens with the railways. Sánchez highlights the investments made, while Wild insists on disruptions and accountability. A technical investigation is essential to determine the causes of any accident. Politically, however, investing more does not automatically prove that enough has been invested or that management has been adequate.

Feijóo does not face the same examination of Spain's central government because he has not yet led it. His record in Galicia and in other administrations is relevant, although it is not equivalent to having implemented his current proposals at national level.

That freedom comes with a trade-off. The candidate can describe how he would organise the executive or which economic reforms he would pursue, but he must explain what resources he would have at his disposal and which decisions he would be willing to negotiate in order to implement them.

Colau knows both sides of the problem. She arrived at Barcelona City Hall through activism and had eight years to see how institutions behave when someone tries to transform them. Her experience allows her to speak with first-hand knowledge of administrative difficulties and the interests involved in the housing market. It also means that the results of her administration can be examined.

In all three cases, the past plays a different role. For Sánchez, it represents accumulated responsibility. For Feijóo, it is a credential he wants to carry into the future. For Colau, it is an experience that strengthens her record while also testing the simplicity of some of her earlier promises.

There is no rule that allows these positions to be assessed automatically. There is, however, one shared requirement: experience must not be used as a substitute for explanations.

Housing, where politics loses its abstraction

All three conversations eventually converge on housing. This is no coincidence. For a significant proportion of people aged between thirty and forty-five, access to a home shapes decisions that once seemed to be a normal part of adult life.

The problem affects employment, mobility, the ability to save and family plans. Some people have been working for years and still do not know where they will be able to live twelve months from now. This uncertainty explains why large economic figures do not always translate into enthusiasm.

Sánchez defends the expansion of public housing and the measures introduced by his government. His challenge is to demonstrate how much of what has been announced has actually become available housing.

Feijóo proposes increasing construction and sets a target of one million homes. His challenge is to explain the timetable, funding, availability of land and mechanisms that would allow this increase in supply to translate into affordable prices.

Colau advocates more intensive intervention in relation to large property owners and the rental market. She proposes expropriations with compensation and specific levies. Her measures require detailed legal and economic assessment, because their effectiveness would depend both on their design and on the ability to implement them.

No proposal should be accepted simply because it sounds ambitious. Nor should it be dismissed without examining the instruments it puts forward.

Building more homes may be necessary, but it will not, by itself, solve every problem of access. Regulating certain market practices may pursue a legitimate objective while also producing unintended consequences if poorly designed. Expanding the public housing stock requires resources, management and time, regardless of who proposes it.

The difference between the candidates is not simply about who considers the crisis more serious. All three acknowledge it. What changes is their understanding of how the state should intervene and which part of the problem they attribute to insufficient supply, the organisation of the market or decisions made by public administrations.

To assess their programmes, citizens need something less spectacular than a grand promise and considerably more useful: verifiable objectives, reasonable deadlines and a clear explanation of costs.

Pensions and the less attractive side of making promises

Pensions reveal another limitation of electoral communication. It is politically profitable to guarantee their purchasing power. Explaining how they will be financed over several decades requires entering a much less comfortable debate.

Feijóo promises to maintain pension increases in line with the CPI and proposes making it easier for people to voluntarily extend their working lives. He links the sustainability of the system to economic growth, productivity and the reduction of certain expenses.

His exchange with Wild about workplace absenteeism introduces a fundamental distinction. A medical leave is not necessarily fraudulent. To estimate potential savings, unjustified absences would have to be identified and separated from legitimate cases of temporary incapacity. Not all social expenditure is money that can be recovered through tighter controls.

Sánchez uses pension increases as an example of a fulfilled commitment. It is a relevant argument, although it does not remove the need to analyse how the system will be financed in the future.

Colau defends a vision of social protection linked to wages, employment and redistribution. Her approach differs from Feijóo's, but it too needs to reconcile benefits with public revenue and overall expenditure.

Spain's Independent Authority for Fiscal Responsibility, AIReF, has warned that formally complying with the pension spending rule does not, by itself, guarantee the sustainability of public finances. This is a more precise conclusion than alarmist messages about an inevitable collapse or absolute assurances that there will be no difficulties.

The issue affects different generations and requires decisions that do not always produce immediate benefits. That is why it is particularly important to distinguish intentions from financial calculations.

Immigration: what each person chooses to focus on

Immigration offers an opportunity to observe three ways of interpreting the same reality.

Sánchez highlights the contribution of foreign workers to the economy and social security contributions, as well as Spain's demographic needs. Colau emphasises coexistence, rights and the history of a society shaped by successive waves of migration. Feijóo places greater emphasis on border control, legal requirements and integration obligations.

All three perspectives address real dimensions of a complex policy. None is sufficient on its own.

Immigration can contribute to employment while also creating additional needs in housing, education and public services. Governments must manage borders and guarantee rights. They must also respond to problems involving coexistence and security when documented facts exist.

Wild introduces experiences from neighbourhoods and municipalities where some residents perceive rapid changes. These perceptions deserve attention, although they cannot replace data. A personal experience does not justify attributing a general behaviour to an entire group. Nor does a national indicator necessarily describe what is happening in a particular neighbourhood.

Crime statistics require particular caution. Arrests, investigations and convictions cannot be treated as interchangeable. Isolated percentages need demographic and social context.

The risk in Sánchez's discourse is responding to local concerns with general economic data. Colau's risk is that a necessary defence against sweeping generalisations may leave too little room to explain concrete integration measures. Feijóo's risk is that firmness may appear to be a sufficient response before its instruments and legal limits have been clearly defined.

The crisis in Ceuta illustrates these differences. Sánchez explains the institutional response and avoids diplomatic attributions that he says he cannot substantiate. Feijóo calls for a firmer response, but must address questions about the orders he would have given. Colau interprets the episode through a broader critique of the European model of migration management.

These are different political perspectives. Establishing what happened and where responsibility lay requires facts, timelines and documentation. An interview can reveal priorities, but it cannot replace that investigation.

Corruption and the double standard

Questions about corruption allow the three leaders to be compared from another angle.

Sánchez responds to questions about his relationship with former associates under investigation. Feijóo must explain corruption scandals involving the PP and controversies connected to his own political record. Colau has to clarify what circumstances would lead her to leave a coalition with the PSOE.

These are not equivalent situations. The standard used to examine them, however, should be consistent.

Criminal liability is individual. An investigation is not the same as a conviction, and personal proximity does not prove involvement in a crime. This principle must apply to every political party.

Politics also involves other responsibilities: how associates are selected, what oversight mechanisms exist and how leaders respond when facts become known.

Sánchez speaks of disappointment and recalls that individual conduct cannot automatically be attributed to the government as a whole. He is right about that limitation, but the question of political oversight remains.

Feijóo acknowledges the seriousness of cases such as Gürtel and admits that his party made mistakes in its response. His credibility when criticising corruption within the Socialist Party also depends on maintaining equally demanding standards when controversies affect the PP.

Colau proclaims zero tolerance and then introduces qualifications concerning the costs of breaking up a coalition. Her experience in government helps explain this caution. What is missing is a clearer definition of the conditions that would make continuing in a coalition unacceptable.

Consistency does not require identical responses to different situations. It requires explaining those differences through stable criteria, rather than according to what is politically convenient at any given moment.

In Spanish politics, however, it is common for a suspicion involving an opponent to become a rhetorical certainty, while an investigation involving one's own side is presented as an injustice until a final judgment is issued. This asymmetry damages trust, even when individual explanations contain reasonable elements.

Political alliances, or what happens after the campaign

The question of alliances runs through all three candidacies.

Feijóo avoids specifying what he would be willing to concede to Vox. Colau ends up leading a candidacy that does not bring together all the forces whose unity she had considered essential. Sánchez defends changes of position and parliamentary agreements as part of the demands of governing without a sufficient majority.

All three have political reasons for explaining their decisions. They must also accept that those reasons will be scrutinised.

Coalition agreements are not a democratic anomaly. They are a common consequence of parliamentary systems. The problem arises when the programme presented to voters appears to take on an entirely different meaning after the election.

It is unreasonable to demand that a candidate anticipate every concession in a future negotiation. But voters can reasonably ask them to identify their essential commitments and explain which boundaries they do not intend to cross.

Nor would it be sensible to regard every change of position as illegitimate. Circumstances change and parliamentary majorities require adaptation. The difficulty lies in distinguishing a justified correction from a promise that was never as firm as it appeared.

Feijóo asks for room to negotiate. Colau defends a pragmatic decision in response to a unity project that could not be completed. Sánchez draws on his experience to explain agreements he had previously rejected or had not anticipated.

Citizens can understand these circumstances. What they should not be asked to do is forget what was promised.

What changes when they sit down with Jordi Wild

There is one aspect of these interviews that deserves attention beyond their content. All three candidates agreed to appear on a platform built outside traditional political media, with an audience that consumes information in very different ways.

That does not automatically make The Wild Project a more authentic space than a journalistic interview. Authenticity does not depend on having a domestic camera, a lengthy conversation or a presenter who speaks without solemnity.

The format offers something valuable: time to develop arguments and to persist when an answer does not seem sufficient. It also has obvious limitations. A spontaneous question may contain questionable assumptions, and checking a figure during a conversation is no substitute for documentary research.

Wild is particularly effective when he forces candidates to be specific. How many homes are available? Which ministries would be handed over? Why does someone return as a candidate after previously ruling it out? These are questions any citizen can understand without needing to know the internal workings of a political party.

At other times, the conversation comes too close to the logic of social media: a personal experience is given the weight of a general trend, or a complex issue is compressed into a choice between two answers. Accessible language does not guarantee accuracy.

In any case, the candidates' presence in this environment reveals a change in political communication. Parties know that part of the public no longer follows their messages solely through press conferences or parliamentary debates. Video clips circulate independently and can reach people who would never listen to an entire speech in Congress.

But appearing where the audience is does not, by itself, restore trust. Closeness is a form of communication, not proof of credibility.

Three candidacies, three different debts

By the end of the interviews, no clear winner emerges. Nor would it make much sense to look for one. The conversations took place under different conditions, and the candidates were not subject to the same type of responsibility.

Sánchez must explain a recent past that includes decisions, results and promises that have been broken or modified. Feijóo has to demonstrate that his proposals form a viable programme and that his principles would withstand the pressures of a coalition negotiation. Colau needs to examine more deeply what she learned from governing and justify why her new measures could overcome limitations she already knows.

Each offers arguments worth considering. None is exempt from questions.

Spanish politics has too often turned the assessment of a record into a comparison with an opponent. If one of its own decisions becomes uncomfortable, a worse decision by the other side is brought up. If a promise lacks clear funding, the government's failures are highlighted. If an agreement contradicts an earlier statement, the complexity of the circumstances is invoked.

Comparisons help voters choose between alternatives. They should not be used to avoid explaining the facts.

For people trying to organise their lives around a salary, rent and increasingly uncertain expectations for the future, political debate can become exhausting. Not because there is a lack of speeches, but because there are too many answers that seem directed at a different conversation from the one that concerns citizens.

All three candidates want to talk about Spain. Their audiences, very often, want to know what will happen to their own lives.

Sánchez presents a record and asks voters to recognise his achievements. Feijóo promises a different approach to governing and asks for trust in his experience. Colau proposes profound changes and argues that action is urgent.

On 29 November, voters will have to decide which project they prefer, but also which uncertainties they are willing to accept. No government can guarantee that everything will turn out as planned. What can be demanded of anyone seeking to lead one is that they explain their decisions according to recognisable criteria, that they do not change their standards depending on who is affected, and that they know how to admit when a promise no longer corresponds to reality.

Trust does not mean believing that a politician will never make a mistake. It means having reasons to think that, when they do, they will not try to convince us that the mistake was exactly what they had promised.


 
 
 

Comments


Stories of the day

News straight to your inbox. Subscribe to our weekly newsletter.

¡Gracias por suscribirte!

  • X

© 2025 by The Global Journey. Powered and protected by Wix

bottom of page